There’s a smell of the 1970s about the Work and Pensions Secretary James Purnell. It’s the sideburns and the ties. It’s the barely suppressed contempt for the idle, the scroungers, the dossers.
You could drape a camel coat around his shoulders and bingo! he’s the coldly brutal boss of a struggling First Division football team telling them to get out there and commit atrocities. Or he’s a softly spoken crime boss telling his heavies which fingers to break - think of a better looking John Osborne in Get Carter.
As David Hepworth says, it won’t be Purnell getting his hands dirty when it comes to enacting his plan to supplement the servile class with the long term unemployed and disabled:
“Forcing” people to work means somebody’s got to do the forcing. Most of us would do anything rather than that.
And what of the people being forced? How are they supposed to look for proper work while they’re toiling in a New Labour camp? There’s a casual demonisation at play here, that pandering to the myth that the jobless are shiftless.
Why else is ‘community service’ being mentioned? You automatically lump the jobless in with petty criminals. How’s that for cementing the image of the unemployed as parasites? As inherently dodgy? People who say being unemployed is a cushy number would seem to never have experienced it first hand.
I just hope that the details of this are all set down clearly. At least more clear than Purnell was on Radio 4 this morning. He was either being evasive or is ignorant of his own policy, both of which are worrying.
Are there going to be plenty of Job Centre staff to help the jobless? When I was looking for work a few years back, the level of sickness at Hove job centre was incredible. Some weeks you couldn’t even sign on because of the staff shortages. I’d go in week after week looking for desperately needed advice but would be turned away because there was nobody who could speak to me.
When I eventually fell into the clutches of Working Links, the private sector company piloting the New Deal in Brighton, thing didn’t get better. I’ve written about this before. The bloke looking after my case couldn’t advise me on Tax Credits because even though he’s been on the training course ‘it was boring’ and ‘he couldn’t remeber anything about it’.
I hope private sector management of people’s lives has improved in the few years since it tried to screw mine. I hope there is no longer just an emphasis on getting clients (for that’s what the jobless are called) into any job at any cost so the company can get its mitts on the cash.
When I expressed an interest in being a journalist (that is, a career rather than a job) and needing the training they looked at me like I had just taken a dump on their desks. The benefit payments couldn’t be transferred to my partner while I took the training because I was the sole client. Eventually we scraped out of the situation with no help from Working Links whatsoever. They still got to keep the money though. Money for nothing, the lucky bastards.
I wouldn’t expect any of this to have improved in the five years since it happened to me. The unemployed in this country rank just above refugees. They’re not people to be helped, they’re scum permitted to scrape by, to be coerced, and made to feel grateful.
Unemployment benefit, you would think, isn’t a meagre safety net open to everybody, it’s a feather-bedded paradise. It would be wrong of us to hope that some of the mutton-headed rubber johnnies who think like this might get a taste of it in the upcoming recession. We’re not like them.